As the NFL Draft approaches, the mock drafts are coming out. But while most mock drafts focus on needs or holes in the roster, Mike Florio went completely off the rails with his Packers pick. Fans are scratching their heads and wondering if it’s genius or lunacy.
Mike Florio’s Crazy Mock Draft Pick: Malaki Starks to the Packers
Florio, who knows the league better than most, went with a wild card in his only mock of the year. Instead of a wide receiver like Steelers star George Pickens (who many have been begging for), Florio has the Packers taking Georgia safety Malaki Starks—a player who fits with the Packers… not so much.
The Packers already have one of the deepest safety groups in the league. Last offseason, they signed All-Pro safety Xavier McKinney and drafted three more safeties, including Evan Williams, who started right away. Second year safety Javon Bullard, a former 2nd round pick, is now fighting for snaps after losing his starting job last season. With free agent Nate Hobbs likely to step into the slot role, where does Starks even fit?
Why This Pick Feels Weird
Starks is good. A 2x All-American from Georgia, he brings experience and leadership to any defense. But his skillset doesn’t scream “need” for the Packers. 4.50 40 yard dash, he’s not elite athletic enough to move to corner (something the Packers did with Damarious Randall years ago). And with how deep the Packers are at safety and slot, adding another body here feels like overkill.
So the question is: are the Packers building a football team or just collecting talent for the sake of collecting talent? Fans love seeing their favorite college stars in green and gold but drafting someone like Starks would feel like a luxury rather than a necessity.
Fan Reaction: Outrage or Genius?
If Florio’s right, Packers fans will riot faster than you can say “draft grades.” The idea of using a high pick on a position already loaded with depth will be met with outrage. Imagine the backlash if general manager Brian Gutekunst passes on high priority targets like wide receivers or edge rushers to take another safety. Some fans will call for his head or even a citizens’ arrest.
But let’s not dismiss Florio’s pick outright. Maybe there’s a method to the madness. Could Starks be a chess piece that can evolve into something more than just a traditional safety, Or is Florio just trolling us all less than 24 hours before the draft?
Other Needs: Enter George Pickens?
Florio’s pick raises an eyebrow, but it also highlights what many fans really want: a big trade for Pittsburgh Steelers wide receiver George Pickens. With the Packers needing a playmaker opposite Christian Watson, Pickens would instantly make the offense better and give Jordan Love the weapons he needs.
Unlike Starks, Pickens fills a need. His big play ability, physicality, and contested catch skills make him a perfect complement to Watson. If the Packers are serious about competing in 2025, trading for Pickens or drafting a wideout seems way more logical than doubling down on safeties.